Does Barfi! deserve an Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film?

Wed, September 26, 2012 12:55pm UTC by 7 Comments
Does  Barfi! deserve an Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film?

Anurag Basu’s film starring Ranbir Kapoor, Priyanka Chopra and Ileana D’Cruz may have many good things going for it, but can all that override the fact that it’s a clever mishmash of ideas from several Indian and international flicks? So does it deserve to be sent to the Academy Awards?

The box office collections of Barfi! are soaring high – when we last checked the trade reports the film had made Rs 100 crores worldwide – with every passing day and night, and the Ranbir Kapoor-Priyanka Chopra-Ileana D’Cruz starrer has been selected to represent India as the official entry to the Academy Awards 2013. But there’s a spiky spoke in the wheel of happiness for the creators of the Charlie Chaplin-esque film.

Everyone who’s well versed with cinema beyond Bollywood has been questioning the originality of Anurag Basu’s sweet and simple tale of a deaf and mute lad. There is endless evidence (written and visual) to prove that Basu’s Barfi! in name of great cinema is a clear and clever case of a cut-copy-paste job. Even BollywoodLife’s Cineswami gave us a long list of films (Indian and international) that have obviously inspired the filmmaker.

And all this makes us wonder if the current rage in cine town is worthy of the shine and glory it is being honoured with. While there’s no harm in Basu seeking inspiration from his favourite films and filmmakers, we expected that he would do a better job than directly lifting scenes and situations from those classics. Does a so-called ‘inspirational’ Murphy-Barfi! deserve to be chosen to be sent to the Oscars? Will it bring us fame or more shame – you decide!

Do vote to tell us if you think Barfi! should be sent for the Academy Awards 2013!

Subscribe to me on YouTube

  • umesh

    Yes,both film “burfi” and “kaksparsh”are obsolute ,geniuslly dirrected movies. de The osker

  • Oorvazi

    Rachana,
    Well put! And I feel there is a difference between plagiarism and inspiration.

  • Ralph

    HECK no it doesnt! They should be ASHAMED of themselves for even MAKING this film and calling it original.. and to top it all, SENDING it to Oscars.. its gonna be a slap in the face for India.

  • sagar

    BARFI = BORROWED AND RECYCLED FOR INDIANS

  • Sudha

    I felt ashamed of myself when I came to know the reality behind the movie.mr basi should apologize to the nation for his theft of our hard earned money and give back what he has made to an orphanage or a old age home.

  • hema sahoo

    yes “Barfi”is the best movie and it should nominated for oscar andit will work best….

  • sunny toppo

    even if it wasn’t a plagiarism, Barfi doesn’t deserve an oscar..

    it is a sweet movie, but not oscar worthy..


Next ARTICLE
ALL NEWS
PREV ARTICLE
ALL NEWS